Expert Bias in Insurance Claim Denials

A treatise by Christopher L. Dion, Esq. Volume One, Chapters 1 through 11, is complete in a beta release.

The Problem

An insurer that denies a claim on the report of a physician, engineer, or contractor it selected and paid can usually point to a complete file and a qualified professional’s opinion. Nothing in that file shows whether the opinion was independently formed. The evidence of bias lies in the expert’s relationship with the insurer and in the expert’s work on other claims.

The Contention

An insurer’s reliance on a biased expert cannot make a claim denial fairly debatable. Where the insurer withholds benefits due, its reliance on a biased expert establishes that the withholding was unreasonable.

The contention does not propose a change in the law. It rests on doctrine the courts have already settled.

This is the first and only comprehensive treatment of the law on the insurance industry’s use of biased experts to deny and underpay claims.

Foundational Principles and Evidence

Volume One develops the contention in eleven chapters.

  1. 1
    Overview
    The problem, the contention, and the expert an insurer retains before any lawsuit.
  2. 2
    Good Faith and Fair Dealing
    The covenant that is the source of an insurer’s obligations in handling a claim.
  3. 3
    The Special Relationship
    Why courts treat insurance differently from other contracts.
  4. 4
    Insurer Duties
    Six duties, including the duty to fully and fairly investigate.
  5. 5
    The Fairly Debatable Standard
    The defense that generally puts an expert’s bias at issue in a bad faith case.
  6. 6
    Neutrality Principles and Standards in Adjudicatory and Quasi-Adjudicatory Settings
    Where bias arises from a financial interest, none of these settings requires proof of actual bias.
  7. 7
    Principles of Bias in Insurers’ Experts
    Bias defined and distinguished from error. Courts infer it from the circumstances.
  8. 8
    Factors for Evaluating Expert Impartiality
    The four categories of evidence from which courts infer bias.
  9. 9
    Layered Retention and the Location of Bias
    The vendors, administrators, affiliates, and attorneys through which insurers retain experts, and who holds the records.
  10. 10
    Discovery of Evidence of Expert Bias
    The evidence courts have ordered produced for each factor.
  11. 11
    Overcoming Insurer Objections to Discovery of Bias Evidence
    Insurers raise the same objections across cases. Courts usually grant the discovery, on narrowed terms.

Volume Two, The Question in Court and Beyond, covers motion practice, case studies, the regulatory framework, and automated claim evaluation in Chapters 12 through 15. The table of contents in the free sample lists both volumes.

The Four Factors

The evidence from which courts infer the bias of an insurer’s expert falls into four categories.

Relational metrics

The size and value of the business relationships from which an expert’s financial dependence may arise.

Reputational metrics

The expert’s pattern of outcomes and the expert’s record before other courts.

Flawed methodologies and procedural irregularities

Departures from sound method in the expert’s work, in the claim at issue and across the expert’s other engagements.

Reasonable measures

The steps the insurer, and any vendor between the insurer and the expert, took to ensure that the expert was neutral and reliable.

Courts have found each category probative in the leading decisions. No court has stated the four collectively as a test.

What the Sample Contains

The Table of Authorities lists 643 authorities, 522 of them decisions, and beside each, every section that cites it. Look up a decision you rely on, or one cited against you. The section numbers show where the volume addresses it.

The sample may be shared freely in its entirety.

Download the free sample (PDF)

Look Up a Case

Volume One cites 522 decisions. The cases page lists each with every section that cites it, and can be searched by case name, court, year, section number, or chapter.

Browse all 522 decisions →

Available to Paid Subscribers

The complete Volume One is available as a single PDF to paid subscribers of Expert Bias Report: Insurance Claims on Substack. Revised chapters replace the earlier ones there as they are released.

The work is licensed to the subscriber who purchased it and to the law firm or organization with which that subscriber practices. Each firm must obtain its own subscription.

This is a beta release. Chapters may be revised and corrected after their release.

Subscribe to Expert Bias Report →